Showing posts with label advice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label advice. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

I have filters in place for precisely these kinds of emails...

And yet, I'm often strangely compelled to look at them. I get this kind of crap from my parents, most of it having to do with religion or god and, nowadays, politics. This one was sent to me by my mom. The line breaks are exactly how they were in the copy I received:

Subject: Profound thought

There was
a blind girl who hated herself because she was blind. She
hated everyone, except her loving boyfriend. He was always
there for her. She told her boyfriend, 'If I could only see
the world, I will marry you.'

One day,
someone donated a pair of eyes to her. When the bandages
came off, she was able to see everything, including her
boyfriend.

He asked
her,'Now that you can see the world, will you marry me?' The
girl looked at her boyfriend and saw that he was blind. The
sight of his closed eyelids shocked her. She hadn't expected
that. The thought of looking at them the rest of her life
led her to refuse to marry him.

Her
boyfriend left in tea
rs and days later wrote a note to her
saying: 'Take good care of your eyes, my dear, for before
they were yours, they were mine.'

What a shallow, selfish bitch! Firstly, what's with the arbitrary conditional, "I'll marry you if I can see"? And the boyfriend "donated" his own eyes? Both of these hypothetical people need intensive therapy.

This must be what abstaining from sex before marriage does to people. Trading your eyes for sex, if that isn't true love...

But there's more!

This is
how the human brain often works when our status changes.
Only a very few remember what life was like before, and who
was always by their side in the most painful situations.

Life Is a
Gift

Today
before you say an unkind word - Think of someone who can't
speak.

Before
you complain about the taste of your food - Think of someone
who has nothing to eat.

Before
you complain about your husband or wife - Think of someone
who's crying out to GOD for a companion.

Today
before you complain about life - Think of someone who went
too early to heaven.

Before
whining about the distance you drive Think of someone who
walks the same distance with their feet.

And when
you are tired and complain about your job - Think of the
unemployed, the disabled, and those who wish they had your
job.

And when
depressing thoughts seem to get you down - Put a smile on
your face and think: you're alive and still
around.

So the real lesson of the boyfriend who gave his eyes away to his shallow sightless girlfriend is that there's always someone out there worse off than you? I'm lost.

No, the real message is one of invalidation and dismissal: Don't complain and don't bitch, because you're actually really lucky, you just don't know it. Want to leave your physically abusive husband? Don't! There are people out there who are lonely! Are you depressed and want to kill yourself? Well cut it out! Babies are being aborted as we speak! Do you hate your job? Don't get another one, just shut your trap and smile!

This tripe makes me so angry.

Tuesday, August 12, 2008

A Helpful Resource on Emotions

It's EQI.org. I'm not exactly sure what the "EQI" stands for, but the site is primarily about emotional intelligence. ("EIQ" would make sense to me—"emotional intelligence quotient"—but EQI? Emotional quotient intelligence?)

Especially interesting is the page on invalidation, where I found some lengthy excerpts taken from this page on hiving advice:

Then there's the other side of the coin...the friends who do not know what to say and do, so, they avoid their friend altogether...the friend in pain. Well, you don't need to say or do anything...just 'be there' for them. They do not expect special words and solutions....they only want to know you care.

They know that not all of their friends are poetic, graceful with words...know 'just what to say'....this isn't a contest of who can make them feel the best. They just want to know you care...that you will merely listen, if they need to talk. And believe me, even if you don't think so at the moment, if you have a hard time facing your friend, you can get a little blank note card and just put the words 'you are in my thoughts' and that is enough...it does show you care. Send it to them. No one ever expects anything 'fancy' or 'just the right thing to say'....please believe that.

Basically, for me, I just need to talk...or type....just 'get it out'...then I can look at it, process it, deal with it, begin the healing, and move on. The very best words a friend can ever say to me is "I'm here for you if you just need to talk". My close friends know that I am not coming to them for answers.....I just need to talk it out ....hear myself say it....

...

Why is it that when a person feels momentarily sad, their friends think it's their cue to stop them from feeling and grieving? Who in the world told them that was healthy? When did they become an expert at how long a person should grieve, and feel, and cry and remember? And just because I do cry from time to time over something, that does not mean that for the rest of my life, each and every day, I will sit and cry, just like this, forever....and that I have ruined my life....forever. Allow me to be sad, just as you would welcome and allow me to be happy....I need it.

My telling someone of an event or something that I am going through, does not mean it's their cue to try to 'solve my problem'...I didn't ask for advice or ask how to grieve.

...

You may help them, upon hearing them explain their situation, to even agree that 'you can understand how and why they would feel that way', even if YOUR OWN thoughts are different...try to understand the way THEY are seeing it.

To your friend, all of what they are feeling is very real and very painful....it's affecting their life.

As a great friend, all you need to do is just lend a listening ear....'be there' for them....don't try to make them look at it differently. If that needs to be done, they will do it on their own, you can't rush it. They have to see their OWN way through.

If you take it as your cue to minimize their situation, 'make excuses' for their enemies, or the ones who are hurting them and causing them grief, what you are now doing is making them feel defensive .....they already feel bad enough, but now they have to further frustrate the situation by defending their feelings and emotions to you.

So, while they try, once again, to tell you why they are hurting, you have just sent them on a detour of the path they are on....now they have to get it all past YOU. And, not only are they upset at the original situation, now they feel alienated and unsupported by you....their friend...the person they just needed to talk to.


Okay, so I'm still bothered by the email exchange with my friend.

Sunday, August 10, 2008

An Email Exchange: On Giving Advice


Aug 7, 2008 at 10:24 PM, AA wrote:

...while I know you're just trying to help me and that you mean the best, I feel angry and frustrated when reading your advice. I mean, I haven't specifically asked for any. I know it's hard to listen to other people's problems and not try to help solve them—I saw many different people learn that lesson in every single quarter of group therapy—but all I want is someone to talk to. There are no answers for anything.



Aug 8, 2008 at 10:08 AM, Friend of AA replied:

I am an optimist. I see the silver lining 90% of the time. I know sometimes that people find this annoying, but when I cannot see the silver lining then I know it is time for me to make changes. Lately, I have been having problems--headaches, stress, etc. And it is only through the nuggets of advice from friends that I have gotten any calming thoughts. Because I am dependent on such advice, I think other people are too.

You are a friend. I care about you. And that is where giving advice comes from-- I just plain dont want to see you upset/sad/stressed. I am sorry that I said things that were frustrating and in the future I will try to stick to advice-free phrases such as 'that sucks' and 'im sorry'.

So I'll admit that I was in a pretty bad mood when I wrote that bit about getting advice. While I think the bad mood is definitely apparent, I haven't changed my stance on anything I said.

My friend's reply makes me angry and frustrated just as if she'd sent me more advice. I feel like she's given me two options: either I hear her advice of I get superficial responses of "that sucks" and "I'm sorry." Is there no in-between? And with either option I don't really get any kind of discussion or conversation—both have the likely unintended consequence of dismissing me and my problems.

Maybe I expect too much from her. Maybe I expect too much out of friendships in general.